Self-service kiosks at McDonald鈥檚 and other fast-food chains have loomed as job killers since they were first rolled out 25 years ago. But nobody predicted what actually happened.
In one of the earliest mentions of kiosks in fast-food settings in 1999, now-defunct trade industry publication Business Information said that McDonald鈥檚 was working to 鈥渄evelop an electronic order-taking system that may eventually replace some of its human equivalents.鈥�
Instead, touchscreen kiosks have added extra work for kitchen staff and pushed customers to order more food than they do at the cash register. The kiosks show the unintended consequences of technology in fast-food and retail settings, including self-checkout. Chains are now experimenting with artificial intelligence at drive-thru lanes, and the experience with kiosks holds lessons for them.
Today, instead of replacing workers, companies deploy kiosks to transfer labor to other tasks like handing off pickup orders, help increase sales, easily adjust prices and speed up service. (Many chains, including Subway, Chick-fil-A and Starbucks, don鈥檛 use them much or at all.)
Kiosks 鈥済uarantee that the upsell opportunities鈥� like a milkshake or fries are suggested to customers when they order, Shake Shack CEO Robert Lynch said on an earnings call last month. 鈥淪ometimes that is not always a priority for employees when you鈥檝e got 40 people in line. You鈥檙e trying to get through it as quick as possible.鈥� Kiosks also shift employees from behind the cash register to maintaining the dining area, delivering food to customers or working in the kitchen, he said.
Some McDonald鈥檚 franchisees 鈥� which own and operate 95 per cent of McDonald鈥檚 in the United States 鈥� are now rolling out kiosks that can take cash and accept change. But even in these locations, McDonald鈥檚 is reassigning cashiers to other roles, including new 鈥済uest experience lead鈥� jobs that help customers use the kiosks and assist with any issues.
鈥淚n theory, kiosks should help save on labor, but in reality, restaurants have added complexity due to mobile ordering and delivery, and the labor saved from kiosks is often reallocated for these efforts,鈥� said RJ Hottovy, an analyst who covers the restaurant and retail industries at data analytics firm Placer.ai. Kiosks 鈥渉ave created a restaurant within a restaurant.鈥�
And in some cases, kiosks have even been a flop. Bowling ally chain Bowlero added kiosks in lanes for customers to order food and drinks, but they went unused because staff and customers weren鈥檛 fully trained on using them.
鈥淭he unintended consequences have surprised a lot of people,鈥� Hottovy said.
Even some of the benefits of kiosks touted by chains 鈥� they upsell customers by suggesting menu items and speed up orders 鈥� don鈥檛 always play out. A recent study from Temple University researchers found that, when a line forms behind customers using kiosks, they experience more stress when placing their orders and purchase less food. And some customers take longer to order tapping around on kiosks and paying than they do telling a cashier they鈥檇 like to order a burger and fries. Not to mention the kiosks can malfunction or break down.
鈥淚f kiosks really improved speed of service, order accuracy, and upsell, they鈥檇 be rolled out more extensively across the industry than they are today,鈥� Hottovy said.
Self-service technology
Kiosks have also been threatened as a fast-food industry response to higher minimum wage laws.
鈥淚 told you so,鈥� former McDonald鈥檚 CEO Ed Rensi said in 2016 after the company expanded kiosks. 鈥淚 and others warned that union demands for a much higher minimum wage would force businesses with small profit margins to replace full-service employees with costly investments in self-service alternatives.鈥�
California this year raised the minimum wage for the state鈥檚 fast food sector workers by US$4 to US$20. It raised a familiar refrain that those workers would be replaced by technology, such as self-service kiosks.
But the quick-service and fast-casual segments of the restaurant industry continue to grow. Staffing levels were nearly 150,000 jobs, or three per cent, above pre-pandemic levels, according to the latest U.S. Labor Department data.
Christopher Andrews, a sociologist at Drew University who studies the effects of technology on work, said the impacts of kiosks were similar to other self-service technology such as ATMs and self-checkout machines in supermarkets. Both technologies were predicted to cause job losses.
鈥淭he introduction of ATMs did not result in massive technological unemployment for bank tellers,鈥� he said. 鈥淚nstead, it freed them up from low-value tasks such as depositing and cashing checks to perform other tasks that created value.鈥�
Self-checkout also has not caused retail job losses. In some cases, self-checkout backfired for chains because self-checkout leads to higher merchandise losses from customer errors and more intentional shoplifting than when human cashiers are ringing up customers.
Fast-food chains and retailers need to do a better job communicating what the potential benefits of kiosks and self-checkout are to consumers and employees, Andrews said.
鈥淲hat I think will be central for customers is that they see how this technology is providing them with more or better service rather than more unpaid busywork,鈥� he said. 鈥淥therwise, the public is just likely to view it as yet another attempt to reduce labor costs via automation and self-service.鈥�
