A Yale study that found Canadian clinics were faster than the U.S. to provide opioid treatment during the COVID-19 pandemic highlights the ethical tightrope researchers must walk when studying addiction while using deception in their research gathering.
The study, entitled 鈥淢ethadone Access for Opioid Use Disorder During the COVID-19 Pandemic Within the United States and Canada,鈥 was published July 23 in the and compared how timely access to methadone was for opioid users during the pandemic between the two countries.
Methadone has been used to prevent overdose deaths for decades, but the treatment remains highly regulated and difficult to access within the United States. In response to the rise in overdose deaths, however, Canada and its provinces relaxed regulations on methadone treatment, the study states.
鈥淭he infectious risks of COVID-19 immediately presented unique challenges for methadone treatment of opioid addiction because methadone treatment both in Canada and the U.S. require someone to frequently come in person to receive their medication,鈥 explained lead study author and assistant professer at the Yale School of Medicine Dr. Paul Joudrey in a telephone interview with CTVNews.ca Thursday.
Joudrey said the study focused on the timeliness of methadone treatment options during the pandemic as 鈥渢here's increasing evidence that the time it takes to get someone on a medication is crucial in terms of ensuring success and entering treatment. In other words, there's evidence that shows that delays in care, even as short as a day or two, can reduce how often people successfully enter care.鈥
The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study of clinics providing methadone for opioid use disorder within the U.S. states of Connecticut, Kentucky, Maine, Massachusetts, Maryland, Michigan, Missouri, New Hampshire, Ohio, Rhode Island, Tennessee, Vermont, West Virginia and the District of Columbia, and the three Canadian provinces of Alberta, British Columbia and Ontario between May 11 and June 17, 2020.
Researchers contacted clinics at their publicly listed phone number, and , pretended to be a 30-year-old patient with opioid use disorder looking to book the next available appointment to receive methadone treatment. The researcher would then document how fast the clinic was accepting new patients and when appointments were available.
Each U.S. clinic was contacted twice by different research team members: once as a patient with Medicaid and once as a patient with no health insurance (self-pay), the study states.
Joudrey said that the deception used in the study鈥 where researchers used a script and pretended to be people with opioid use disorder 鈥 was necessary.
鈥淭his approach, which is sometimes called an audit study or a secret shopper study, has been used previously in addiction studies,鈥 he said, adding that the study methods were submitted to the Yale Institutional Review Board and passed. 鈥淚n the end, we're using this data to advocate for patients, to advocate for this vulnerable population and collecting data from their perspective is to show a larger audience, 鈥榟ere's what it's like to be someone calling, asking for help when this is a really difficult situation.鈥欌
鈥淜ind of the only way to capture that data from the perspective of a person with addiction is to use deception,鈥 he said.
Founding Director of the Centre for Professional and Applied Ethics and Professor at the University of Manitoba Arthur Schafer disagrees, and said the question of ethics in a study depends on a number of factors.
鈥淭here's got to be good evidence that the deception is necessary and that if it is necessary, that the least deceptive study design has been adopted,鈥 Schafer explained in a telephone interview with CTVNews.ca Thursday.
Schafer questioned why the researchers could not have called the clinics and asked about methadone appointment availability without the deception.
鈥淚f I were on the ethics committee that had to approve this, the question would be, well, 鈥榳hy do you need to deceive people?鈥欌 he said.
When asked if the study could have been done without deception 鈥 Joudrey said 鈥渘o.鈥
鈥淭he answer is no鈥f you use no deception and you go to the clinics and you survey them directly鈥verything is above board in a sense鈥he problem, though, is it brings in biases in the end because there's a natural tendency amongst all human beings to give the answer the person wants to hear,鈥 he explained.
Schafer was unconvinced.
鈥淪o their belief is that a person who presents herself or himself as an addict, needing methadone treatment or needing treatment, will not get the same answer as a researcher who calls,鈥 he said. 鈥淭hey believe that that the clinics wouldn't answer them honestly. But I can't see why not.鈥
Schafer said the Yale ethics committee should have challenged the study to justify their beliefs.
鈥淥n the face of it, it seems to me that they're not trying to expose corrupt or incompetent or unethical behaviour on the part of the clinics,鈥 he said. 鈥淭hey're simply asking about wait times and whether the pandemic has made a difference to the wait times. I can't see why a clinic would have any interest in giving an inaccurate answer to someone who asked the question that was openly and honestly, as opposed to someone who deceptively pretends to be an addict seeking treatment.鈥
Schafer offered an alternative research method he believes could have been undertaken to prove that the deception 鈥 which he admitted was 鈥渟mall potatoes鈥 鈥 was necessary.
鈥淭he deception seems, as I said earlier, de minimus, I'm not sure that it's necessary and I'd like to hear more careful justification. Had I been on the research ethics board, I wouldn't have given that approval,鈥 he said.
鈥淎pproach the same clinic both honestly and separately, deceptively, and see whether the responses you got differed,鈥 Schafer continued. 鈥淚 would have challenged them for evidence that that there was a significant risk of bias if they didn't use the deception.鈥
When asked if the research team followed up with the clinics contacted in the study to disclose that they had in fact been deceived, Joudrey said no, as 鈥渋t might cause more harm than good鈥 for the clinics to find out they had been deceived, and as they did not collect any information on who had answered the phone, there was 鈥渘o one to call back, in a sense.鈥
In a follow up email to CTVNews.ca, Schafer said that Joudrey should have been clearer on 鈥渨hat harm he expected to occur if he informed the clinics,鈥 and questioned whether they had brought up this point in advance with the research ethics board.
鈥淲hy did the research ethics board of Yale University not require a debriefing? The people deceived were entitled to an explanation and entitled to see the results of the study...and to have an opportunity to ask question,鈥 Schafer wrote.
Joudrey said the researchers put several safeguards in place to ensure that their study did not take away access to care for actual opioid use disorder patients.
鈥淪o first off, we put a cap on the number of times we would try to call it a clinic, and that was three,鈥 he said. 鈥淪o if we called clinics and we didn't get an answer, we got a busy signal, after three times we just we documented that that was the case.鈥
Joudrey said if the clinic didn鈥檛 answer within three tries the team would stop contacting them, and if there was a busy signal, the maximum amount of time they would stay on the line was capped at two minutes.
鈥淲e would give up. We would we would count that as a call because the idea there with those we were interpreting the fact that the busy signal means they're busy,鈥 he explained.
And the final 鈥渁nd most important鈥 safeguard the researchers put in place was to not make any actual appointments 鈥 something worked into the official scripts.
鈥淲e gave an excuse to not book the appointment, and then we ended the call,鈥 he said. 鈥淭hat way there was no appointment slot taken up that could go to a real patient.鈥
Joudrey said because researchers were not gathering information on anyone working on the clinic who answered the phone, they could not be considered 鈥渁 subject of the research鈥 and therefore would not be considered 鈥渉uman subject research鈥 and impact the ethical valuation of the study when it was before the review board.
Schafer said ethical review boards shoulder a lot of responsibility when assessing studies, and while deception in research 鈥渃an be justified,鈥 there are several factors to consider.
鈥淭he first question, is the importance of the research so trivial, unimportant, and wouldn't justify the use of deception?鈥 he continued. 鈥淚n this case, the objective of the research is to explore ancillary harms from the COVID-19 pandemic, not just the harms that come to people who are infected and hospitals and clinics that are overrun, but the cost to people who need other health care services鈥 So I would say that the researchers are exploring an important issue with respect to people who have addictions.鈥
Schafer said the second criterion is whether or not the study goal or objective is so socially important that it warrants or justified breaking or bending the rules on deception, but it boils down to 鈥渋s the deception necessary?鈥
Schafer said it is 鈥渄iscrediting鈥 to university research, to social science research and corrodes the researchers and the people they employ to be deceptive.
鈥淭hat's a cost and moral cost. It's a cost worth paying if you've got a really important goal and there is no other honest or non deceptive way of achieving it,鈥 he said.
Schafer said that despite there being evidence the deception in the Yale study was 鈥渋nconsequential鈥 he found it 鈥渋mplausible鈥 that it was necessary.
鈥淭hat's why I find it important, the claim that it was necessary. I find it implausible. If someone might give a dishonest answer in order to make themselves look better or in order to cover up some wrongdoing - there are all sorts of reasons why the methadone clinics might have given dishonest answers, but none of them seems to apply here,鈥 he said.
Joudrey and his team found that slightly less than 90 per cent of clinics in both the U.S and Canada accepted new patients during the pandemic 鈥 with about a third of the clinic who were not accepting new patients citing COVID-19 as the reason why.
Researchers also found the wait time for methadone in the U.S. were much longer than Canada, with approximately 3.5 to 4.1 days compared to 1.9 days.
In both countries, clinics with an open access model -- where patients can present for treatment without a prior appointment -- provided timelier treatment access. But in the U.S., only about 30 per cent of clinics offered open access, compared with 59 per cent in Canada.
鈥淭he study definitely affirms that this open access model clearly has advantages for meeting patient鈥檚 needs,鈥 Joudrey said. 鈥淭hat kind of an important message, I think, to get out.鈥
----
Edited by Michael Stittle
A $2.14-billion federal loan for an Ottawa-based satellite operator has Canadian politicians arguing about whether American billionaire Elon Musk poses a national security risk.
Specialist divers surveying the wreckage of the US$40 million superyacht that sank off Sicily in August, killing seven people including British tech tycoon Mike Lynch, have asked for heightened security to guard the vessel, over concerns that sensitive data locked in its safes may interest foreign governments, multiple sources told CNN.
Twenty-seven year 麻豆影视 reporter and anchor John Vennavally-Rao shares his story of what it was like to have an ostomy bag as part of his health-care battle. 'I鈥檓 grateful for what it did to extend my life,' he writes in a personal column for CTVNews.ca.
The British Columbia election campaign is set to officially start today, with Lt.-Gov. Janet Austin issuing the writ for the Oct. 19 vote.
A northern Ontario man is facing a $12,000 fine after illegally shooting a moose near the Batchawan River.
A new study is adding to emerging research showing that exposure to metals such as cadmium, uranium and copper may also be associated with the leading cause of death worldwide, cardiovascular disease.
Unusual flippered feet are making their way into the Saint Lawrence River this weekend. Led by underwater explorer and filmmaker Nathalie Lasselin, volunteer divers are combing the riverbed near Beauharnois in Mont茅r茅gie to remove hundreds of tires that have been polluting the aquatic environment for decades.
The Lebanese militant group Hezbollah announced that it fired a barrage of missiles at a military base deep inside Israel early Sunday following an Israeli airstrike more than a day earlier that killed at least 37 people, including one of the militant group鈥檚 senior leaders as well as women and children.
A sea lion swam free after a rescue team disentangled it near Vancouver Island earlier this week.
A man is facing numerous drug trafficking charges after Dufferin OPP seized a large assortment of drugs and weapons in Orangeville earlier this week.
The London Police Service (LPS) is currently investigating a suspicious death in the east end.
The British Columbia election campaign is set to officially start today, with Lt.-Gov. Janet Austin issuing the writ for the Oct. 19 vote.
A sea lion swam free after a rescue team disentangled it near Vancouver Island earlier this week.
A northern Ontario man is facing a $12,000 fine after illegally shooting a moose near the Batchawan River.
A body has been found in the vicinity where a woman went missing on the Ottawa River near Pembroke, Ont. while kayaking Tuesday night, according to the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP).
Donald Trump returned to North Carolina on Saturday, stumping in the southern battleground state with direct appeals to women, claiming he would be a better champion for them than U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris, who is vying to become the first female president.
Sheba, a 50-year-old seal at the Cornish Seal Sanctuary in southwest England, has far surpassed the average lifespan for seals and could be the oldest in captivity in the world.
The more Chelsea Walsh talked to the eccentric fellow American who seemed to pop up in every square and cobblestone street of Ukraine's capital, the more she got creeped out.
Specialist divers surveying the wreckage of the US$40 million superyacht that sank off Sicily in August, killing seven people including British tech tycoon Mike Lynch, have asked for heightened security to guard the vessel, over concerns that sensitive data locked in its safes may interest foreign governments, multiple sources told CNN.
The Lebanese militant group Hezbollah announced that it fired a barrage of missiles at a military base deep inside Israel early Sunday following an Israeli airstrike more than a day earlier that killed at least 37 people, including one of the militant group鈥檚 senior leaders as well as women and children.
A $2.14-billion federal loan for an Ottawa-based satellite operator has Canadian politicians arguing about whether American billionaire Elon Musk poses a national security risk.
Foreign Affairs Minister Melanie Joly says close to 45,000 Canadians are in Lebanon, months after warning there is no guarantee Ottawa can evacuate them if the situation deteriorates further.
The federal firearm buyback program has cost taxpayers nearly $67.2 million since it was announced in 2020, but it still hasn't collected a single gun.
A new study is adding to emerging research showing that exposure to metals such as cadmium, uranium and copper may also be associated with the leading cause of death worldwide, cardiovascular disease.
For some young people, a popular method for getting a quick high is by misusing laughing gas 鈥 and lately, that鈥檚 in the form of nitrous oxide from products sold by the company Galaxy Gas.
Looking after an adult with severe autism can be a full-time job. Ask any parent who has a child severely affected by autism spectrum disorder 鈥 it鈥檚 a job that can get more difficult as the child becomes an adult.
If something looks too good to be true, it might be. That's the message from Saskatchewan horticulturists after customers have come into their stores hoping to buy purple apple trees this month.
The owner of the shuttered Three Mile Island nuclear power plant said Friday that it plans to restart the reactor under a 20-year agreement that calls for tech giant Microsoft to buy the power to supply its data centers with carbon-free energy.
Lebanese authorities on Thursday banned walkie-talkies and pagers from being taken on flights from Beirut airport, the National News Agency reported, after thousands of such devices exploded during a deadly attack on Hezbollah this week.
Kathryn Crosby, who appeared in such movies as 'The 7th Voyage of Sinbad', 'Anatomy of a Murder,' and 'Operation Mad Ball' before marrying famed singer and Oscar-winning actor Bing Crosby, has died. She was 90.fff
'Saturday Night Live' will have a slew of famous faces to help kick off its historic 50th season when the show returns later this month.
The death of the Tragically Hip鈥檚 lead singer Gord Downie united fans across Canada in their grief, but in many ways pulled his bandmates apart.
It is not a great time to be a coffee drinker. In general, coffee bean prices are the highest they've been in more than a decade.
The maker of the popular party game Cards Against Humanity is accusing Elon Musk's SpaceX of trespassing on and damaging a plot of vacant land the company owns in Texas.
The Canadian Food Inspection Agency says a recall of Nutrabolics brand Feed Me Vegan Real Food Protein & Oats bars due to undeclared milk has been expanded.
Tattoos are becoming more common in today's society and, as a result, appear to be more acceptable in the workplace than they used to be.
The end of the day 鈥 when school, extracurricular activities and homework are (hopefully) finally done 鈥 is the window that many kids have for downtime. It can be a struggle to convince them not to go on their phones.
While slang may come and go, experts say the phenomenon behind them, which constantly churns out brand-new bon mots, is as old as language itself.
Jonathan Aranda homered for the second consecutive game, helping Taj Bradley and the Tampa Bay Rays beat the Toronto Blue Jays 3-2 on Saturday.
Kiefer Sherwood spent several nights last spring chasing Quinn Hughes around the ice and generally pestering the Vancouver Canucks.
Cole Haas is more than just an avid fan of the F.W. Johnson Wildcats football team. He's a fixture on the sidelines, a source of encouragement, and a beloved member of the team.
General Motors (GM) has issued a recall for 38,000 vehicles for safety risks related to a software glitch, Transport Canada reported in a notice on Wednesday.
Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov has accused Tesla CEO Elon Musk of 'remotely disabling' his Cybertruck, which had been sent to the frontline of Russia's war in Ukraine.
An Ontario man says it is 'unfair' to pay a $1,500 insurance surcharge because his four-year-old SUV is at a higher risk of being stolen.
Cole Haas is more than just an avid fan of the F.W. Johnson Wildcats football team. He's a fixture on the sidelines, a source of encouragement, and a beloved member of the team.
Getting a photograph of a rainbow? Common. Getting a photo of a lightning strike? Rare. Getting a photo of both at the same time? Extremely rare, but it happened to a Manitoba photographer this week.
An anonymous business owner paid off the mortgage for a New Brunswick not-for-profit.
They say a dog is a man鈥檚 best friend. In the case of Darren Cropper, from Bonfield, Ont., his three-year-old Siberian husky and golden retriever mix named Bear literally saved his life.
A growing group of brides and wedding photographers from across the province say they have been taken for tens of thousands of dollars by a Barrie, Ont. wedding photographer.
Paleontologists from the Royal B.C. Museum have uncovered "a trove of extraordinary fossils" high in the mountains of northern B.C., the museum announced Thursday.
The search for a missing ancient 28-year-old chocolate donkey ended with a tragic discovery Wednesday.
The Royal Canadian Mounted Police is celebrating an important milestone in the organization's history: 50 years since the first women joined the force.
It's been a whirlwind of joyful events for a northern Ontario couple who just welcomed a baby into their family and won the $70 million Lotto Max jackpot last month.
A six-year-old girl who was reported missing in northern B.C. earlier this week remains unaccounted for, and "significant resources from across the province" have joined in the search, police said Saturday.
Volunteers and staff members gathered along Vancouver鈥檚 Stanley Park Seawall Saturday to pick up litter as part of International Coastal Cleanup Day.
A heritage home in Vancouver suffered "extensive damage" in a fire that broke out late Saturday morning, according to firefighters.
Toronto police are investigating a shooting in Scarborough that left one person injured Saturday night.
A pedestrian was struck by a vehicle involved in a collision in Scarborough Saturday evening, Toronto police said.
A 23-year-old man has been arrested after one person was found dead at a home in Richmond Hill Saturday morning.
Milla White from Cochrane literally drew her way into a meeting with former boxer and actor Mickey Rourke.
The water coming from your taps might be a bit murky Saturday, but Calgary remains on schedule to end all water restrictions on Sunday.
For 12 hours Saturday Canadian Pacific Kansas City (CPCK) employees, service personnel and corporate teams rode spin bikes to raise funds and awareness for charities focusing on housing homeless veterans in Canada and the U.S.
A potential move to LeBreton Flats for the Ottawa Senators is still years away, but questions and concerns are already being raised about what to do with the Canadian Tire Centre.
The Taste of Wellington 2024 wraps up Saturday in Ottawa.
A body has been found in the vicinity where a woman went missing on the Ottawa River near Pembroke, Ont. while kayaking Tuesday night, according to the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP).
Montrealers can get used to taking a stroll on several car-free streets during the summer in the years to come thanks to a new commitment from the city.
Three men were injured after trying to subdue a man armed with a knife during afternoon prayers at a Montreal-area mosque Friday afternoon.
Unusual flippered feet are making their way into the Saint Lawrence River this weekend. Led by underwater explorer and filmmaker Nathalie Lasselin, volunteer divers are combing the riverbed near Beauharnois in Mont茅r茅gie to remove hundreds of tires that have been polluting the aquatic environment for decades.
The Edmonton Police Service is looking for a person of interest in connection with a suspicious fire that destroyed a multi-unit building and damaged several townhomes earlier this week.
Tattoos are becoming more common in today's society and, as a result, appear to be more acceptable in the workplace than they used to be.
Two people have been charged after a daylight shooting in Red Deer earlier this week.
Halifax Regional Police warned the public of a series of high-value thefts targeting retail stores Friday.
Pictou County District RCMP is investigating a fatal crash that occurred in Thorburn, N.S., Saturday.
A proposal for additional parking to accommodate upgrades at the Irving Pulp & Paper Mill in Saint John, N.B., would add an estimated 500 parking spots at Wolastoq Park.
The search for a missing six-year-old boy in Shamattawa is continuing Friday as RCMP hope recent tips can help lead to a happy conclusion.
A herd of dogs paid visit to patients and residents at Riverview Health Centre during an annual event that lifts spirits and wags tails.
While slang may come and go, experts say the phenomenon behind them, which constantly churns out brand-new bon mots, is as old as language itself.
Fire officials are investigating after a fire completely destroyed the community fridge in the Cathedral neighborhood.
The last two months after losing her daughter Bella have been extremely difficult for Kyla Thomson.
Regina police arrested three youths in connection to a bear mace incident at a Regina high school on Friday.
The Cambridge Professional Fire Fighters鈥 Association held their annual Muscular Dystrophy Boot Drive on Saturday.
Protests were held in front of Kitchener City Hall on Friday, both for and against LGBTQ2S+ inclusive education and queer rights in schools.
Police said the pedestrian, a 52-year-old man, was taken to an out-of-region hospital with life-threatening injuries and the driver of the vehicle failed to remain at the scene.
The 75-year-old building, formerly the Waskesiu Chamber of Commerce building, was relocated to the Parks Canada compound on the edge of the townsite.
Saskatchewan RCMP major crimes unit is investigating after a man鈥檚 body was found on Sweetgrass First Nation.
Motors were roaring, and tires were spinning as Saskatoon's biggest names in motocross gathered together for the 50-year anniversary of the club's founding on Saturday.
Ontario鈥檚 police watchdog is investigating after an Ontario Provincial Police officer discharged his firearm at a 36-year-old man in near Moonbeam, Ont., on Friday night.
For some young people, a popular method for getting a quick high is by misusing laughing gas 鈥 and lately, that鈥檚 in the form of nitrous oxide from products sold by the company Galaxy Gas.
An Ontario woman is among the dozens of people who have come forward to allege that they were sexually abused by London-based businessman Mohamed Al Fayed, the former chairman and owner of Harrods.
A motorcyclist has died following a serious collision that took place in London鈥檚 south end on Friday afternoon.
The London Police Service (LPS) is currently investigating a suspicious death in the east end.
The St. Thomas police is asking the public for help locating a missing man.
The Barrie Skateboard Association (BSA) hosted a unique competition at the City's Skate Park on Saturday to celebrate its 25th anniversary, which showcased the park's importance and the growth of skateboarding in the region.
A man is facing numerous drug trafficking charges after Dufferin OPP seized a large assortment of drugs and weapons in Orangeville earlier this week.
One person is in hospital after an e-bike crash in Orillia on Thursday.
The Amherstburg Freedom Museum is celebrating a year of festivities in anticipation of its 50th anniversary in 2025.
The St. Clair College golf teams were successful at the Niagara Knights Invitational tournament on Friday.
A LaSalle high school is celebrating its emerald anniversary this weekend, with everyone who has ever walked its halls invited to return.
A man who was found dead behind a curling rink in Nanaimo, B.C., earlier this month was the victim of a homicide, police confirmed.
A sea lion swam free after a rescue team disentangled it near Vancouver Island earlier this week.
A six-year-old girl who was reported missing in northern B.C. earlier this week remains unaccounted for, and "significant resources from across the province" have joined in the search, police said Saturday.
A pair of runaway pigs are in the custody of an animal sanctuary in the Okanagan after evading police and volunteers for hours earlier this week.
The Red Bridge, a historic landmark in Kamloops, B.C., was completely destroyed by fire early Thursday morning.
Animal protection officers in British Columbia have rescued three pit bulls 鈥 including one that gave birth to 10 puppies 鈥 from a rat-infested home in Kelowna.
Despite the heavy rain, plenty of muscle turned up for United Way鈥檚 annual Pull the Bus fundraiser in Lethbridge Friday.
Lethbridge County has rescinded its fire restriction as a result of the recent cool, wet weathr.
The Lethbridge Hurricanes kicked off the 2024-25 season on a winning note Friday night, defeating the Edmonton Oil Kings 3-1 in a game played at VisitLethbridge.com Arena.
A northern Ontario man is facing a $12,000 fine after illegally shooting a moose near the Batchawan River.
Following an outbreak of COVID-19 on its continuing care floor and just ahead of the flu season, St. Joseph鈥檚 General Hospital in Elliot Lake has opted to re-introduce a universal masking policy until further notice.
A 26-year-old driver from Surrey, B.C., has been charged with three counts of criminal negligence causing death and bodily harm in a crash that killed two youths in northern Ontario last year.
Newfoundland and Labrador's chief medical officer is monitoring the rise of whooping cough infections across the province as cases of the highly contagious disease continue to grow across Canada.
A 16-year-old biennial event aimed at fostering business in the country's eastern Arctic and northern regions has been cancelled indefinitely as a dispute unfolds between Inuit in Canada and a Labrador group claiming to share their heritage.
Jim Lester鈥檚 farm hopped on the cow-cuddling trend in early August, and his time slots have been pretty well sold out ever since.
The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at 麻豆影视. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop.聽Read about us.
