麻豆影视

Health

    • New report on contentious breast cancer screening study divides researchers

    Share
    TORONTO -

    A new paper has called into question the scientific process behind the Canadian National Breast Cancer Screening Study (CNBSS) from the 1980s, a contentious study that has divided researchers for years.

    Researchers from Toronto's Sunnybrook Research Institute, the Ottawa Hospital, the University of British Columbia, the University of Alberta and Harvard Medical School this week, alleging that the original study had significant flaws, particularly in the randomization aspect of the research.

    The done in the 1980s at 15 screening centres in six provinces: Nova Scotia, Quebec, Ontario, Manitoba, Alberta and British Columbia. Close to 90,000 women aged 40 to 59 participated in the study.

    Its purpose was to determine whether cancer screening programs helped saved women鈥檚 lives, and assigned the participants into two groups 鈥 one with women aged 40 to 49 and 50 to 59 that received mammograms and another control group where both age sets had a single physical exam.

    All participants were followed by the study for several years.

    Over the five year screening period, the CNBSS found that 666 invasive breast cancers were diagnosed in the group that received a mammogram and 524 were diagnosed in the control group that received a physical exam. Of those diagnosed, 180 women in the mammography group and 171 women in the control group died of breast cancer during the 25-year follow up period.

    The overall risk ratio for death from breast cancer diagnosed during the screening period and the cumulative mortality from breast cancer was similar between the women in the group that received mammograms and those in the control group, the CNBSS found.

    Researchers then determined from that data that mammograms for women aged 40 to 49 did not reduce death rates from breast cancer for women at average risk of the disease.

    The CNBSS findings have influenced healthcare policy and guidelines on when women should be able to participate in screening programs, with the  currently not recommending breast cancer screenings with mammograms for women aged 40 to 49 if they do not have any pre-existing factors, such as a direct family member that had breast cancer or the BRCA gene.

    In an emailed statement to CTVNews.ca Tuesday, CTFPHC co-chair Dr. Brenda Wilson said the organization 鈥渃onducts rigorous, detailed evidence reviews to formulate guidelines. Our guidelines, including those on breast cancer screening, have been recognized as the best in the world鈥ne reason for this is the careful and detailed process that the Task Force uses to weigh evidence, which is available in its guideline documentation.鈥

    When asked if the CTFPHC would revisit said guidelines in light of the new paper鈥檚 allegations, the statement said 鈥渢he Task Force integrates the best available evidence into its guidelines. When there are substantive changes to that evidence, the Task Force updates a full review of the body of evidence, including any new evidence. We do not comment on individual studies or opinion pieces without going through that process.鈥

    RESEARCHERS DIVIDED

    One of the co-authors of the new paper, radiologist Dr. Jean Seely, who is head of breast imaging at The Ottawa Hospital, told CTVNews.ca in a telephone interview Tuesday that experts around the world had 鈥渓ong suspected鈥 that there were issues with the science of the CNBSS.

    鈥淭hey [the CNBSS] were the only randomized controlled studies out of eight to show no benefit from screening mammography,鈥 she said. 鈥淎 lot of questions were raised over the years [which] showed that there probably had been a problem with the randomization process, that allowed for more women with clinically advanced cancers to be allocated to the screening arm of the study.鈥

    Seely says those suspicions are what pushed her and her fellow researchers to examine the CNBSS more closely, and in the process of their investigation determined that the trial participants had a clinical breast exam prior to being assigned to one of the two trial groups.

    The new paper suggests that the breast examination influenced whether the women were put in the control group or the group which received mammogram screenings.

    鈥淲e have very credible eyewitness testimony showing that that happened at two different sites,鈥 Seely said. 鈥淥n the ground evidence is that 鈥 with the best of intentions -- the nurses who had examined the women were allocating them to the mammography arm with the intention of getting them attention.鈥

    Lead study author Dr. Martin Yaffe of the Sunnybrook Research Institute echoed Seely鈥檚 concerns.

    鈥淥ur research reveals a number of protocol violations within the CNBSS related to how patients were randomized into the trial groups 鈥 to receive breast screening or not,鈥 Yaffe said in a release. 鈥淕iven these significant issues, the trial results are unreliable and should not be used to inform policies on breast cancer screening.鈥

    The authors of the paper argue that the CNBSS should not be informing screening guidelines due to the 鈥渃orruption of the randomization process,鈥 according to Seely.

    鈥淲e now know that many women who had symptomatic breast cancers were actually recruited鈥o it really should not inform screening guidelines today,鈥 Seely said, adding that mammogram photo quality was poor during the trials time period.

    Seely says she was 鈥渁stonished鈥 that the alleged data corruption could have occurred and the study was still published.

    鈥淚t鈥檚 disturbing to me as well that we have conclusive evidence that this happened鈥 think as a Canadian myself, I felt a bit embarrassed or ashamed,鈥 she said. 鈥淚 think the bottom line is that women should not be hurt by this and they should be empowered to have good health and get screening.鈥

    However, Dr. Cornelia Baines, professor emerita at the Dalla Lana School of Public Health at the University of Toronto, who worked on the CNBSS, categorically denied the new papers evidence in an email and telephone conversation with CTVNews.ca.

    鈥淪peculation and anonymous remarks do not constitute evidence,鈥 Baines wrote in an email.

    The JMS paper does, however, from named individuals, including employees and doctors at certain mammography sites

    鈥淭he JMS article suggests women age 40-49 were seeking screening mammograms in the CNBSS because of symptoms," Baines said. "In fact women鈥檚 access to diagnostic mammograms regardless of age was available in our universal health care system. Unlike the U.S., Canadian women do not need to seek free care in research trials.鈥

    鈥淣urse examiners did not need to thwart randomization protocol because of a positive clinical exam,鈥 she continued. 鈥淎 positive exam required a referral to the study鈥檚 surgeon, who was totally free to order a diagnostic mammogram.鈥

    Baines says that the screening centre co-ordinators were independent of the examiners, and that there were only four criteria for entry into CNBSS: a woman鈥檚 age, that the women were not pregnant, there was no history of breast cancer and they had not had a mammogram in 12 months prior to the study.

    鈥淲e expected women to be honest and virtually all were,鈥 she wrote. 鈥淚n 2019, the BMJ rated our 2014 paper on the CNBSS 25 year results as one of the five best it had published in the decade.鈥

    鈥淚 will briefly tell you 鈥 it is radiologists who do not like our study [and] have been pushing this for three decades, you have to wonder why after 30 years of such attacks the CNBSS is still highly regarded by people other than radiologists,鈥 Baines said in a telephone conversation with CTVNews.ca

    THE HUMAN COST

    Currently, there is no universal breast cancer screening program across the country. A woman in her 40s in B.C. can get screened for breast cancer, as can a woman of the same age group in Nova Scotia. In Ontario however, a woman needs a referral from their family doctor.

    The authors of the new paper argue that screening should be available to any woman in her 40s to catch possible disease quicker.

    For law professor Jennifer Quaid, early screening is something she often thinks about after her experience with breast cancer.

    鈥淚 got excellent care and treatment鈥ut what makes me angry is that it was preventable. I think it should have been picked up earlier,鈥 the University of Ottawa professor said in a telephone interview with CTVNews.ca Tuesday.

    Quaid, who is now in her 50s, found a small lump in November 2019 but put off seeing her doctor due to career demands and the subsequent COVID-19 pandemic where in-person visits to the doctor鈥檚 office were often delayed or discouraged. In the summer of 2020, she saw her doctor who requisitioned a mammogram for her.

    鈥淭he tech came back in and said 鈥榯he radiologist wants to have a quick chat with you,鈥 at which point I knew something was wrong,鈥 Quaid said. She ended up being diagnosed with stage three breast cancer that required a full mastectomy and a full lymph node reduction.

    鈥淚'd just come off a very successful sabbatical where I had gotten every grant I had applied for and written some pretty significant papers,鈥 Quaid said. 鈥淪o I felt like I was ready to launch and all of a sudden it's like somebody just pulled the floor out from under you. That was probably the worst moment.鈥

    Quaid had surgery, and went through chemotherapy, then radiation until mid-March 2021.

    鈥淚 don't want to seem like I'm laying blame,鈥 she said. 鈥淵ou know, people do the best they can. But my GP knew that 鈥 have breast cancer in my family, but not my mother, and I don't have any sisters and my grandmothers did not have breast cancer. So under the Ontario rules I didn鈥檛 qualify [for screening].鈥

    Quaid wants breast cancer screening to be offered to women earlier, as analysis on the tumours removed from her body during surgery revealed they had been there for at least one to two years.

    鈥淚 will never be able to go back to exactly how I was before,鈥 she said. 鈥淚 also lost a year of productive work at the height of my career and those things I will never get back. So if I can prevent one other person from going through that, it's worth it.鈥

    CTVNews.ca Top Stories

    Why brain aging can vary dramatically between people

    Researchers are uncovering deeper insights into how the human brain ages and what factors may be tied to healthier cognitive aging, including exercising, avoiding tobacco, speaking a second language or even playing a musical instrument.

    The union representing some 1,200 dockworkers at the Port of Montreal has overwhelmingly rejected a deal with their employers association.

    A man who was critically injured in a police-involved shooting in Hamilton late Sunday afternoon has died in hospital, says the province鈥檚 police watchdog.

    Canada

    World

    Politics

    • Murray Sinclair鈥檚 family members say the late justice and senator has been laid to rest according to his wishes.

    • Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced voters in Cloverdale鈥擫angley City will pick their next member of Parliament on Dec. 16.

    Health

    Sci-Tech

    Entertainment

    Business

    Lifestyle

    Sports

    Autos

    Local Spotlight

    For the second year in a row, the 鈥楪ift-a-Family鈥 campaign is hoping to make the holidays happier for children and families in need throughout Barrie.

    Some of the most prolific photographers behind CTV Skywatch Pics of the Day use the medium for fun, therapy, and connection.

    A young family from Codroy Valley, N.L., is happy to be on land and resting with their newborn daughter, Miley, after an overwhelming, yet exciting experience at sea.

    As Connor Nijsse prepared to remove some old drywall during his garage renovation, he feared the worst.

    A group of women in Chester, N.S., has been busy on the weekends making quilts 鈥 not for themselves, but for those in need.

    A Vancouver artist whose streetside singing led to a chance encounter with one of the world's biggest musicians is encouraging aspiring performers to try their hand at busking.

    Ten-thousand hand-knit poppies were taken from the Sanctuary Arts Centre and displayed on the fence surrounding the Dartmouth Cenotaph on Monday.

    A Vancouver man is saying goodbye to his nine-to-five and embarking on a road trip from the Canadian Arctic to Antarctica.

    • Weather watchers were treated to an exceptionally rare display on Friday evening as rare cloud formations filled Vancouver skies.

    • For some shoppers it was Nov. 1, but for others the first hints of Christmas - saccharine treats, festive-fragranced candles and gaudily wrapped gift sets - were being noticed in stores long before the final Halloween decor had been cleared.

    • Thousands of people are expected to gather in downtown Vancouver on Monday to observe the city鈥檚 100th Remembrance Day ceremony.

    • Toronto is expected to see an economic boost to the tune of nearly $300 million thanks to Taylor Swift鈥檚 upcoming Eras Tour, which will be making a stop in Canada鈥檚 largest city for a six-show run later this month.

    • One man was transported to hospital early Monday morning after a stabbing in the northwest end of the city, Toronto police say.

    • A pair of 105-mm howitzers bark constantly as they turn plywood tank targets into kindling kilometres away on the windswept landscape of one of Canada's largest military bases.

    • Two semis were among the vehicles involved in a multi-vehicle crash that brought westbound traffic along Stoney Trail Northwest to a standstill on Sunday.

    • NEW THIS MORNING

      NEW THIS MORNING

      An Ottawa boy with a rare disease will be getting the chance to see Taylor Swift in concert after the winner and organizers of an auction held on his behalf gifted the tickets to him.

    • CTVNewsOttawa.ca looks at Remembrance Day ceremonies in Ottawa.

    • After months of controversy surrounding a dog park in Ottawa's west end, a solution has been reached to divide the park in half.

    • The employers association at the Port of Montreal locked out nearly 1,200 longshore workers, bringing a halt to traffic at the port.

    • An elementary school in Greenfield Park on Montreal鈥檚 South Shore is closed after it was the target of an alleged arson attack.

    • Though most businesses are expected to be open on Remembrance Day, there are some establishments that will be closed to commemorate the holiday.

    • Monday is Remembrance Day, a time to honour armed forces members who have died in the line of duty.

    • Boasting 2,300 square metres of skating space at its new location, Edmonton's Rollers Roller Rink believes it is the largest in Canada.

    • A Cape Breton senior recalls her life in German-occupied France, and her mother鈥檚 death, during the Second World War.

    • It's been a trip to cherish for a group of Canadians visiting Belgium this week to honour the legacy of Indigenous soldiers.

    • A pillar in Canada鈥檚 history was honoured in Winnipeg Sunday afternoon, with thousands showing up to pay tribute to the life and legacy of the late Murray Sinclair.

    • Winnipeg police have identified two men involved in a stabbing incident earlier this week.

    • There will be two ceremonies taking place in Regina for Remembrance Day, hosted by the Royal Canadian Legion.

    • Regina author Valerie Crowther is celebrating the release of her book 鈥榃ar Letters: Linking Lives in the Second World War.鈥

    • It was a somber day at Mosaic Stadium as members of the Saskatchewan Roughriders officially cleaned out their stalls and closed the book on the 2024 season.

    • A man has been charged after a stabbing at an apartment building in Kitchener.

    • The Guelph Police Service is putting out a warning after two deaths in the downtown area.

    • Two new tributes to Canada鈥檚 veterans have been unveiled at the Elmira Cenotaph.

    • Saskatchewan RCMP are searching for a suspect after a man was seriously injured in a farm-related incident in Montreal Lake.

    • It was a somber day at Mosaic Stadium as members of the Saskatchewan Roughriders officially cleaned out their stalls and closed the book on the 2024 season.

    • The Regina Rams claimed the Hardy Cup after a hard fought battle against the Saskatoon Huskies 19-14 on Saturday in the first all Saskatchewan U-Sports western conference final since 2002.

    • Emergency crews responded to the scene on Road 68/Highway 2 east of Thamesford around 7 p.m.

    • On Friday, the Sarnia Police Service (SPS) received a report of an alleged abduction in the area of Kathleen Avenue and Walnut Avenue.

    • 11 AM:WATCH LIVE

      11 AM:WATCH LIVE

      The events will start at 10:15 a.m. with a parade that forms up in front of the Delta London Armories, marches east on Dundas Street and turns north onto Waterloo Street to Dufferin Avenue, the west to the Cenotaph.

    • A group of former NHL players faced off against York Regional Police officers in Newmarket Sunday afternoon to raise funds for Special Olympics programs across the province.

    • A driver is facing multiple charges after a multi-vehicle collision on Highway 400 early Sunday morning.

    • The agreed statement of facts was read to the court on Friday in the case of Alex Williams, the 24-year-old jail guard charged last fall with smuggling cannabis and tobacco into Central North Correctional Centre in Penetanguishene.

    • 11 AM:WATCH LIVE

      11 AM:WATCH LIVE

      Representatives of the Windsor Veterans Memorial Services Committee, military representatives, wreath bearers, government officials, and members of the public will attend the Cenotaph at City Hall Square for the outdoor service.

    • One person has been arrested after Chatham-Kent Police Service (CKPS) received multiple complaints about an alleged drunk driver.

    • More details have been released about a police investigation at the Ambassador Bridge that connects Windsor, Ont. and Detroit, MI.

    • Environment Canada says heavy rain and winds could cause power outages on Vancouver Island as an "intense" storm system is set to hit the B.C. coast Sunday.

    • Six deer were struck by vehicles in six different locations in a six-hour period on B.C. highways on Saturday, according to the transportation ministry.

    • The union for locked-out port workers in British Columbia says the BC Maritime Employers Association cut off talks in less than an hour Saturday, refusing to budge on a final offer that the union has so far rejected.

    • The emergency department at South Okanagan General Hospital in Oliver, B.C., will be closed for 31 hours this weekend, the second such closure in a week and the third since the start of November.

    • Police in Kamloops, B.C., are reminding parents and guardians to check their children's Halloween candy after receiving a report of a mother finding a razor blade in one of her daughter's treats.

    • More than two years after Alannah Brown and Douglas Barker were found dead north of Penticton, police are asking for help identifying a vehicle they believe was associated with the crime.

    • The Southern Alberta Recreation Association is officially announcing the Town of Taber as next year鈥檚 host for the Southern Alberta Summer Games.

    • The Lethbridge Hurricanes broke open a close game with three goals in the first two minutes of the third period as they defeated the Warriors 7-3 in a game played Friday night in Moose Jaw.

    • There might not a lot snow just yet, but many southern Albertans are still itching to get outdoors.

    • Police have arrested a 15-year-old in connection with a break-in and $50,000 in damage done to the Centennial Arena in Elliot Lake in September.

    • Mayors of the five largest cities in northern Ontario met in North Bay the last two days to discuss a range of critical issues impacting their cities and the region.

    • Residents in the Sault expressed concerns ranging from vandalism to privacy invasions during recent consultations on the city's plan to install automated speed enforcement cameras.

    N.L.

    Shopping Trends

    The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at 麻豆影视. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop.聽Read about us.

    Stay Connected
    Follow 麻豆影视