麻豆影视

Skip to main content

Canadian court to consider when minors can be sentenced as adults

Canada's top court is seen, Friday, June 16, 2023 in Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld Canada's top court is seen, Friday, June 16, 2023 in Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Share
TORONTO -

Canada's highest court is set to hear arguments on Tuesday on when a young person can be considered an adult for sentencing purposes.

The result may reshape how Canada sentences youth and could, a lawyer told Reuters, set an example for other western countries to follow.

At issue are the cases of I.M. and S.B., two young men who cannot be identified under Canadian law because the crimes they were convicted of took place when they were minors.

I.M. was convicted of first-degree murder following a 2011 stabbing, when he was 17.

S.B. was convicted of first-degree murder following a 2010 shooting, when he was 16.

Both were sentenced as adults, to life sentences with no parole eligibility for 10 years.

They are appealing their sentencings to Canada's Supreme Court, arguing prosecutors did not meet their obligation in rebutting the presumption of the accuseds' "diminished moral blameworthiness."

Under Canadian law, people accused of crimes committed when they were under 18 are considered less culpable for their actions because of immaturity. The prosecutor can apply to have them treated as adults.

A 2008 Supreme Court decision put the burden on prosecutors to rebut the presumption a youth has diminished moral blameworthiness in order for them to be treated as an adult.

Lawyers for I.M. and S.B. argue the bar for rebutting that presumption needs to be high and should require the presentation of expert evidence.

They also argue it is not enough for an offense to be serious: A young person has to have the maturity to be sentenced as an adult.

The government argues in its court filing the seriousness of an offense is relevant to assessing moral blameworthiness, that expert evidence is not required and that the I.M. and S.B. were properly sentenced as adults.

It is common for youth convicted of serious offenses to be sentenced as adults, according to University of British Columbia law professor Debra Parkes. Of the 102 murder cases involving youth she studied, prosecutors sought adult sentences in 89 and they were imposed in 62, all of them life sentences.

"It's actually more the norm to sentence young people as adults when the charge is murder," she said.

Nader Hasan, lawyer for I.M., said a Supreme Court decision could clarify when a child can be sentenced as an adult - something now done inconsistently.

"The presumption should be that kids are sentenced as kids unless there's a really good reason not to. And that really good reason has to come in the form of expert evidence," he said.

"I'm hopeful that this case, if we're successful and if we start seeing more youth sentences, can serve as a positive example of what youth sentencing in a democracy ought to be."

(Reporting by Anna Mehler Paperny; Editing by Sam Holmes)

CTVNews.ca Top Stories

麻豆影视 is projecting the New Brunswick Liberals will form a majority government in the province, returning to power for the first time since 2018. Leader Susan Holt will become the first female premier of the province.

The University Health Network is making masks mandatory as respiratory illness season ramps up.

The investigation into the sudden death of a 19-year-old Walmart employee over the weekend is ongoing in Halifax.

Two men charged in the killing of former Air India bombing suspect Ripudaman Singh Malik have pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in a British Columbia court.

Mounties on Vancouver Island say one person is dead and another is presumed to have drowned after two vehicles were found submerged in a river following heavy rains that washed out roadways across British Columbia.

Local Spotlight

A Springfield, Ont. man is being hailed a 'hero' after running into his burning home to save his two infant children.

Hortense Anglin was the oldest graduate to make her way across the platform at York University's Fall Convocation ceremony this week. At the age of 87, she graduated with an Honours degree in Religious Studies.

Looking for a scare with good intentions this Halloween season? The ghosts and ghouls of Eganville, Ont. invite families to tour the Haunted Walk at Lekbor Manor.

The image of a sleepy Saskatchewan small town with 'not a lot going on' is a well-known anecdote. However, one Saskatchewan company is hoping to change that 鈥 and allow communities both on and off the beaten path to share their stories and advertise what they have to offer.

A Moncton, N.B., home has been donated to the Friends of The Moncton Hospital Foundation and will be transformed into a resource hub for people living with cancer.

A Nova Scotia man crossing Canada on foot is passing through southwestern Ontario. Trevor Redmond is perhaps better known as the 鈥楩ellow in Yellow.鈥

John Cantin vividly remembers opening day for his Victoria diner. Stress levels were high, tables were full, and one of the most popular menu items couldn鈥檛 be freed from the unyielding grip of the waffle maker.

A Manitoba professor is warning the public after a book on regional mushrooms that he suspects is AI-generated was delisted from Amazon.

A B.C. judge has issued a decision in a years-long dispute between neighbours that began with a noise complaint over barking dogs, crowing roosters and quacking ducks 鈥 awarding $15,000 in damages to the plaintiffs in the case.

Stay Connected